The two versions
- Centreboard “DL” (dériveur lesté): external ballast stub plus an unballasted pivoting board. Draft 0.70 m up, 1.38 m down (guy07800, Hisse-et-Oh, 24 June 2012; the same figures from the owner Marsianer on Segeln-Forum, 1 September 2006).
- Fin keel: draft about 1.12 m (T1mm, Segeln-Forum, 15 September 2025) or 1.10 m (juliusse, Hisse-et-Oh, 10 October 2019, who knows only the DL and passes this on as hearsay).
Marsianer also gives, for his boat: length overall 7.30 m, waterline 6.20 m, beam 2.50 m, displacement 1330 kg and ballast 480 kg, and a weighed total of 2500 kg with trailer, which he sets against the brochure weights. He sails mostly inland on the Steinhuder Meer, always with the board up. bil56 (Hisse-et-Oh, 17 January 2016) explained that 6.90 m is the hull length and that the overall length of 7.30 m includes the pulpit and rudder. He linked a PDF on Jeanneau’s old-boats archive site.
What owners say about sailing
Fin keel
- Owners who sailed or raced the fin keel speak well of it. suspended-7494 (Hisse-et-Oh, 4 February 2008), who raced against fin-keel and DL Tonics, found the fin keel a performer that points well and can carry its full sail. naoned (same day), who tried a fin keel, found the performance quite honourable. Raz Blanchard (8 November 2017) relays a sister who sailed a fin-keel Tonic with the Glénans in Sardinia on a windy off-season trip: it went well, felt safe and made ground upwind. He adds that period boat tests noted a big upwind difference in a breeze, with the DL lacking stiffness and not pointing.
- A sailor who raced against both (anonymous post, 6 March 2008) rates the fin keel very highly and the DL very poorly. Pellechevent (Hisse-et-Oh, 19 May 2019), who raced against friends’ DL Tonics some fifteen years earlier, says the fin keel is stiff and seaworthy and the DL points badly and luffs up without warning. Ca d’Oro (23 January 2015) agrees: the fin keel is very good in a breeze.
Centreboard
- The criticism is poor pointing and sudden luffing in gusts (suspended-7494, 4 February 2008, who beat the DLs with a Brio DL; Pellechevent, 19 May 2019).
- Several DL owners are more positive. tonic56 (23 June 2012) found the performance satisfactory, and advises reducing the main early to keep pointing when beating in a breeze; by 23 January 2015 he added that from about 20 knots the boat no longer makes ground to windward and sails square tacks (with a furling genoa).
- golfhotel (12 and 13 May 2019), who bought a DL, says trim, load distribution and sail condition often matter more than intrinsic stiffness. He accepts that the DL with its engine well struggles to point well above 25 knots, but says it does much better than its reputation with sails made for the job, and that for coastal cruising it is one of the most versatile and comfortable trailer-sailers at an affordable price.
- JLPIER (2 and 3 January 2023), who refitted a DL, reports being surprised by how stiff it is and how well it goes to windward. In steady 27 knots, gusting 35, off the Golfe de Fos, he says he sailed about 35 degrees off the apparent wind; he corrected this to nearer 40 degrees in 28 knots with a genoa that was not working well, and kept 35 degrees in lighter wind with the genoa unrolled.
- Gildas29 (8 and 11 November 2017, 16 July 2018), who rebuilt a DL, finds that it pounds upwind and tends to be ardent (weather helm); he regretted not buying a First 235. He still says it copes with more than 30 knots with good sails and three reefs.
- Odysseus (Segeln-Forum, 6 October 2025), who has trailered both versions, finds the fin keel more pleasant on the road because you see better in the mirrors. Laurids Madsen (6 October 2025) sails the centreboard version, which is slightly heavier because the ballast sits higher, and says that otherwise, with the deeper draft, they have few compromises to make. Planke (15 September 2025) says that on a boat this size even a fin keel will probably never stop you finding a harbour, even in the southern Adriatic or on the south coast of Sicily; very small harbours are more often full than too shallow. He would not choose between 1.20 m and 70 cm (board up) on that basis. Odysseus advises working the board from time to time so it does not seize.
- On Segeln-Forum, Henning (15 September 2025) expects the difference in sailing between the two versions to be negligible and says to choose by the depth where you sail.
Version not stated
- Swanee (4 February 2008) sailed the first Tonics at the Glénans in a hard breeze and found them lively. He put the luffs down to too much sail or helm errors.
- Pierre3, who taught at the Glénans for two years (3 January 2023), found the boat average to windward with little helm feel; he added on 5 January that the Glénans boats had poor sails.
Numbers
- On the HN rating (the French handicap system), a thread starter (19 May 2019) puts the DL at 7 and the fin keel at 9, and works out one point at about 1.7% of speed, so about 3.4% between them. Kerhulcoq (18 May 2019) says that in the OSIRIS table the DL has the same coefficient as the Kelt 707 DL.
- grauwal (Segeln-Forum, 15 September 2025) gives a Yardstick number of 113 for the boat in general. He calls it not a top figure but not bad for a 23-footer.
- guy07800 (24 June 2012), who sails a First 235, quotes the Tonic’s DL as 0.70/1.38 m against 0.66/1.75 m for the First 235 lifting keel, and says the lifting keel performs much better than the Tonic’s DL. See the comparison article.
Hull shape
The hull has a hard chine. A poster whose account has since been deleted (11 May 2019) says that a chined hull generally heels quickly and then settles on the chine, and Kerhulcoq confirms the Tonic settles on its chine. Gildas29 (8 November 2017 and 16 July 2018) and patbzh (17 May 2019) say the boat pounds upwind in a chop.
Which to choose
- If you will beach it often or need to reach shallow places: DL (Kerhulcoq, 10 and 11 October 2019; golfhotel, 19 August 2019).
- If you want the best sailing: fin keel (Annobon, Hisse-et-Oh, 28 December 2022; Raz Blanchard; Pellechevent).
- The DL adds a mechanism to maintain. See the centreboard article.
Sources
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Tonic 23 : Vous en pensez quoi?” (in French): tonic56 (23 June 2012), guy07800 (24 June 2012), Raz Blanchard and Gildas29 (8 November 2017, 16 July 2018).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Tonic 23 vs kelt 707“: thread of 11 to 20 May 2019 (golfhotel, Pellechevent, Kerhulcoq, deleted-125509 and others).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “TONIC 23“: naoned, Swanee, suspended-7494 (4 February 2008).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “TONIC 23“: posts of 6 March 2008.
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Le Tonic 23 est il un (le meilleur) choix dans mon cas“: tonic56, Ca d’Oro (23 January 2015).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Que pensez-vous du voilier Tonic 23“: Annobon, JLPIER, Pierre3 (28 December 2022 to 6 January 2023).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “TONIC 23“: jerom-826, golfhotel (August 2019).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “TONIC 23 quillard“: juliusse, Kerhulcoq (10 and 11 October 2019).
- Segeln-Forum, “Tonic 23” (in German): Marsianer (1 September 2006).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Hors tout Tonic 23“: bil56 (17 January 2016).
- Segeln-Forum, “Besichtigung Jeanneau Tonic 23 – Schwachstellen?“: T1mm, grauwal, Henning, Planke (15 September 2025), Odysseus and Laurids Madsen (6 October 2025).