The rudder hangs on the transom. It is a sandwich of fibreglass skins over a core, and old ones can soak up water.
What broke
- July 2010. ELMOEL broke his rudder at the lowest fitting (Hisse-et-Oh, 19 July 2010). He asked whether a repair with a stainless plate on each side would work, whether the part can be bought, and whether to make one in wood. jeanquem (23 July 2010) said the same thing had happened to him the week before.
- April 2021. Caudalie_fr (30 April 2021) broke his rudder at the waterline on the first outing of the year. His guess: the previous August, the boat swung at anchor over a rocky bottom and the heel of the rudder scraped on the falling tide and the antifouling and gelcoat were breached. The boat stayed in the water all winter, water got into the rudder and rotted the core. He asked for the dimensions of the rudder (3 May 2021); nobody had replied when the page was saved.
- October 2023. Ptitefleur (18 October 2023) broke his rudder at the lower fitting. It is fibreglass skin over polyurethane foam. He asked about repairing or remaking it and about modifying the rudder stock.
What the advice was
- bil56 (19 July 2010): a repair with a metal plate will not hold; remake the rudder in epoxy-laminated plywood. If you still have both pieces it is not a very big job.
- jeanquem (23 July 2010) suggested all-moabi plywood, which a specialist boat joiner (Atelier de Guyenne) recommends for rudders. ELMOEL chose okoumé plywood with epoxy because moabi was not in stock and had to be ordered by the pallet.
- JLPIER (19 October 2023): breaking is a classic on these old sandwich rudders, which are probably full of water. In his view a repair would only be a stopgap. He rebuilt his own completely, as a plywood sandwich with biaxial glass and epoxy, and says it needs little equipment, just method. He has posted the details in the “Tonic 23” Facebook group.
- Caudalie_fr leaned towards marine plywood, to have a varnished wooden rudder above the waterline. He also said he could get Sapelli plywood locally.
Grounding the centreboard version
Quallenschubser (Segeln-Forum, 6 October 2025) pointed out a specific risk of centreboard boats: the keel can swing up but the rudder cannot. In shallow water the rudder should not be the deepest point, because grounding on it can badly damage the blade or its fittings. IchoTolot agreed the rudder would probably be torn out of its mounting.
Before it happens
- Inspect the rudder after any scrape, as Caudalie_fr wishes he had.
- On the hung rudder, Herman Hartman (Zeilersforum, 6 August 2026) names the tiller fitting as a point that can rot.
Sources
- Hisse-et-Oh, “SAFRAN TONIC 23” (in French): ELMOEL, bil56, jeanquem (19 to 23 July 2010).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Safran Tonic 23dl“: Ptitefleur (18 October 2023), Kerhulcoq (18 October 2023), JLPIER (19 October 2023).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Safran cassé Tonic 23“: Caudalie_fr (30 April and 3 May 2021).
- Segeln-Forum, “Besichtigung Jeanneau Tonic 23 – Schwachstellen?” (in German): Quallenschubser, IchoTolot (6 October 2025).
- Zeilersforum.nl, “Markt Tonic 23: deze kopen of afwachten?” (in Dutch): Herman Hartman (6 August 2026).