First 235
- Same waterline length of 6.20 m, and the First 235 came two years after the Tonic. The First 235 has a lifting keel (0.66/1.75 m) against the Tonic DL’s centreboard (0.70/1.38 m). Its interior is almost a copy of the Tonic’s. He says more First 235s than Tonics race, and that raising the keel takes 60 turns of the winch. (guy07800, Hisse-et-Oh, 24 June 2012.)
- Capucin (9 and 11 November 2017): the First 235 is faster than the Tonic by about 3 minutes per hour (he clarified minutes, not knots), but the Tonic weighs about 100 kg more at the same waterline length and is more comfortable.
- tonic56 (23 June 2012), a former Tonic owner: the Tonic is much more spacious, the 235 sails much better. For a programme of 2 or 3 weeks of coastal cruising plus 2 or 3 day trips, he would take a Tonic again.
- sunsea (26 February 2008): the Tonic is better for cruising, with the engine in a well, a big double berth under the cockpit, a good bow berth and a fully enclosed toilet. The First is probably better upwind, and downwind they should be alike, except that on the First the engine can be raised. golfhotel (same day) adds that the 235 has a Bénéteau-type lifting keel whose mechanism needs checking after 20 years, and that the Tonic is slower but roomier and more comfortable, and still very seaworthy.
- A First 235 owner of 20 years (3 April 2007, user name not shown): the Tonic is an excellent family cruiser and seaworthy, but neither very quick (especially as a DL) nor very pleasant at the helm. The 235 has excellent performance, a surprising close-hauled angle, and exceptional helm pleasure up to force 4; above force 5 it becomes like a wild horse and you must reduce sail a lot. He measured it at 1340 kg for IRC with engine and full tank.
- gem_two (22 March 2015), who owned a First 235 and sailed alongside a Tonic and First 24s: the Tonic has a very large interior for its size; the 235 a smaller volume but excellent performance and a transom engine that does not drag; the First 24 a little more headroom and volume but limited room round the table.
- A poster (27 March 2007, user name not shown) says to choose by programme: the Tonic gives space with honest performance, the 235 performance (especially upwind) with honest comfort.
Fantasia
- tonic56 (23 June 2012), who had a Tonic DL and then a Fantasia: the Fantasia is the same boat, bigger, with an inboard engine. It is heavy for its size, hardly better in light air, and the gap grows with the wind, especially upwind. He rates the Tonic’s original upholstery and lining better than the Fantasia’s. On 26 January 2015 he added that the deck plan is the same, the Fantasia has an extra aft locker and a partitioned aft cabin, and the Tonic’s forward double berth is as large or larger. The Fantasia points better, especially in a breeze, passes the chop much better and hardly gets wet. Downwind the difference is smaller. For this size he would take a Tonic again. On 9 October 2025 he repeated that the Tonic is an excellent compromise of habitability and performance for its size, and that the Fantasia is too heavy and lacks performance below 15 knots.
- bugcrusher (8 November 2017): the Tonic is fine for coastal trips and he leaves offshore sailing in it open; he says the Fantasia has proved itself in all weathers and offshore.
- Capucin (9 November 2017): the Fantasia weighs double for only 30 cm more waterline, so it moves more softly in waves. At the Glénans, he watched a Tonic gallop at the end of its chain in a strong blow next to a Fantasia.
- A poster whose account has been deleted (9 November 2017): the big difference is that the Tonic is road-trailable and the Fantasia is not. If road transport is not in the plan, the Tonic has little advantage over a Fantasia.
Gib’Sea 242
- ALJOUB (23 January 2015), who owns a 242 integral centreboard: Tonics are more common (750 against 247), and the two are designed alike and equal in size and layout. The 242 weighs 1750 kg.
- pierre 2 the minimalist (23 January 2015) says the 242 has more headroom (1.80 m against 1.70 m) and a cast plate under the hull. Arno33 (25 January 2015) says the headroom differs by only 3 cm (180 against 177 cm). Babar74 (23 January 2015) calls it the Tonic’s real competitor, one that ages better inside.
- golfhotel (14 September 2018) notes that the 242 is the only boat offering the Tonic’s comfort and volume with an integral centreboard, but its forward berth is very small in that version. jerom-826 knows it well: nice cockpit and aft cabin, but not very seaworthy, more a boat for coastal camping, and the Tonic is the more seaworthy (14 September 2018, and 19 August 2019).
Kelt 707
In a May 2019 thread started by a Kelt 707 owner: the Tonic wins on headroom, separate toilet and interior volume (golfhotel, 16 May 2019). The Kelt is simpler to ground thanks to its built-in legs (the owner and golfhotel), and goes better to windward in a seaway (earendil, 15 May 2019). The thread starter notes that the Tonic replaced the Kelt 707 at the Glénans (14 May 2019). In the OSIRIS handicap table the DL Tonic and the DL Kelt have the same coefficient (Kerhulcoq, 18 May 2019).
Sun Odyssey 24
xabia (25 January 2015): the 24.1 and 24.2 are heavy but not very stiff, and as far as he remembers were built in Poland. ness-2 (26 January 2015): forget them, he has never read a positive comment. vendesir2 (10 November 2017) tried first to find a Tonic, which turned out to be much sought after, and bought a Sun Odyssey 241 instead. He calls it very lively and says its interior is exactly the Tonic’s, a little more modern.
Jouët 680
camus (Hisse-et-Oh, 27 February 2016), who owned a Jouët 680, wanted to move up to a Tonic. Hungry bird thought the Tonic seems a little livelier. The Jouët seems more robust, and its board is a simple steel plate, which he says makes it heel more. arnaudp noted that the Jouët is much smaller (6.55 m against 6.90 m for the Tonic, a more recent Harlé design) and, he says, without the Tonic’s headroom. Yann-3 posted extracts from a used-boat magazine on both boats and advised looking at the Eolia 25, Feeling 720 and Jouët 24, which he called much more seaworthy, for the same money as a Tonic (28 February 2016). camus’s marina place limits him to a beam under 2.50 m.
Sun Way 21
No thread about it was found in the sources used here. Capucin wrote (9 November 2017) that he got shaken up as much in his old 700 kg Sun Way as in a Fantasia three times as heavy, but with less comfort.
Sources
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Tonic 23 : Vous en pensez quoi?” (in French): tonic56, guy07800 (23 and 24 June 2012), bugcrusher, Capucin, deleted-64866 (8 to 11 November 2017).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Le Tonic 23 est il un (le meilleur) choix dans mon cas“: ALJOUB, pierre 2 the minimalist, Babar74, Arno33, tonic56, xabia, ness-2 (23 to 26 January 2015); tonic56 (9 October 2025).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Tonic 23 First 235“: posts of 1 March to 3 April 2007.
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Tonic 23 versus First 235“: sunsea, golfhotel and others (26 and 27 February 2008).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Tonic 23 QR / First 235 QR“: gem_two (22 March 2015).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “jouet 680 ou tonic 23“: Yann-3, camus, Hungry bird, arnaudp (27 and 28 February 2016).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Tonic 23 vs kelt 707“: thread of 11 to 20 May 2019.
- Hisse-et-Oh, “déplacement réel du Tonic 23“: golfhotel, jerom-826 (14 September 2018).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “TONIC 23“: jerom-826 (19 August 2019).