Knowledge

Engine & electrics

Living with the outboard well

The Tonic 23 has an outboard well, offset to starboard. Owners say it takes practice going astern and adds drag under sail. They also report which engines fit the well, and what happened when owners moved the engine to the transom.

Last updated October 23, 2026

According to Wikipedia, the Tonic 23 is normally fitted with a small outboard of 3 to 6 hp; an inboard was an option. As built, the outboard sits in a well inside a cockpit locker, offset to starboard (La Contrie, Hisse-et-Oh, 18 March and 1 April 2018); some owners have it on a bracket on the transom instead.

Going astern

Several owners describe reversing as the weak point, especially in wind. The advice is simple: go slowly and plan the manoeuvre. One owner (guy07800, 23 June 2012) says a four-blade propeller gives very good handling in harbour.

At the Glénans, where the school ran Tonics with 6 hp two-cylinder Yamaha two-strokes, motus (19 May 2010) found astern a little marginal: the exhaust goes into the propeller, and the well brakes the boat a lot. He thought a four-stroke would do better and preferred two-cylinder engines, which are quieter and smoother than a single.

Mäffi (boote-forum.de, 23 January 2004), who had had his Tonic for five years, says the boat goes astern under power only very reluctantly.

Drag under sail

In the well the engine cannot be lifted clear of the water, so the leg drags while sailing (guy07800, 23 June 2012). An owner with the engine on a transom bracket reports no drag problem. Kerhulcoq says that sailing in company with another Tonic that had its outboard lifted, he saw no speed difference (19 May 2019). estey replied that it is hard to believe a long shaft and propeller cost nothing.

vrobert78 (21 July 2017) has the engine in the well and notes a fairly large drag; his boat sails better on starboard tack.

Smell and water

  • Marsianer (Segeln-Forum, 1 September 2006) runs a 10 hp outboard in the well. Because the well is open to the cockpit, the boat smells slightly of exhaust.
  • sunsea (8 March 2008), who had his boat delivered new in 1989, says the well had two thick rubber lips at the bottom to fair the flow and limit water rising when sailing at speed. There is no original hatch. He closed the bottom with a thick rubber plate with a slit, slid the engine through it without the propeller, and fitted the propeller from outside. That worked and lasted.
  • The same owner (sunsea, 26 February 2008) had one pin-head leak at the well, where hull and deck meet.

Trim

Because the engine sits to starboard, spread the load in the boat to keep it level. Gran (5 January 2017) says to distribute weights so the boat sits level. Yolling (18 June 2020) has a slightly greater list to starboard and compensates with the lockers inside. The fuel tank can sit in the starboard locker next to the engine (Stephane33160, 1 April 2018: 20 litres maximum, plus a 5 kg gas bottle).

Stephane33160 found his fin-keel boat with 150 to 180 kg of sand, about 120 litres in bags, under the port bench and aft berth, put there by a previous owner to level the boat. Posters suggested taking the sand out and seeing whether the boat floats level with engine and fuel in place; one thought the boat could have about 5 degrees of static list.

Which engine

One owner recommends a 6 hp Yamaha for the well: enough power, reliable and light.

Other owners:

  • How much power. Dagget (18 May 2010) thought 6 hp enough unless you sail where the current is strong. KOALA-5 gave a rule of about 5 hp per tonne, but said an 8 hp would be more comfortable against short chop or wind in a narrow passage given the boat’s windage. Leicar8 would take an 8. AICA added: with a high-thrust propeller. PHIL (15 July 2015) asked why anyone takes a 9.9 hp four-stroke: a 6 or 8 hp has enough torque if the dinghy-type propeller supplied with it is replaced by a thrust propeller. In the Segeln-Forum Henning (15 September 2025) thought 8 hp one or two sizes too big for this boat, and later that day said a 5 hp petrol engine with a thrust propeller should be more than enough, since more power mostly makes bigger bow and stern waves. Odysseus (15 September 2025) said a petrol outboard is fine. space*cadet (15 September 2025) said that in many cases a 4 or 5 kW electric engine with a suitable battery is the answer, and for long-distance ambitions the smallest possible diesel, currently probably a Yanmar 1GM10.
  • Fitted in the well. gilou-79 (6 April 2016) swapped a Honda 9.9 for a Tohatsu 6 hp long shaft in the well: 15 kg lighter, and the engine can turn about 20 degrees in the well, which he says makes harbour manoeuvres very easy. He motors at about 4 knots when there is no wind (7 April 2016), and says the boat sits on its lines with the 15 kg less. Yolling (18 June 2020) fitted a four-stroke Yamaha 8 hp, replacing a tired 9.9 Mercury two-stroke. It was about 2 cm too long for the well, so he cut into the inner part of the well and sealed it with a piece of soft rubber. He thinks a different angle or thickness on the 5 to 6 cm marine plywood engine mount might have avoided that. Flavour (21 June 2021) fitted a Yamaha 8 hp, with almost no room to spare. Stephane33160 (20 June 2021) runs a Yamaha 9.9 FE in the well with no problem. WTS (19 June 2020) has a 2004 Honda BF6 and doubts there is room for anything bigger. ELMOEL (16 July 2015) had a Honda 6 hp tuned to 8, which is possible because both share the same chassis.
  • Fitting. Annobon (28 December 2022): choose an engine size that you can still lift out of the well for winter. A Selva high-thrust propeller passes. Bert65 (7 August 2026), who had a fin-keel Tonic for a few years, points out that with a high-thrust propeller you cannot lift the engine out while afloat, because the propeller will not pass through the hole, though the boat goes along well. NICOLAS25 (15 July 2015, speaking from a Kelt 760) advised checking the length between the mounting board and the transom before buying a four-stroke, since the head of an 8 hp four-stroke can be too big.

Propeller, power loss and the “well kit”

  • ELMOEL (Hisse-et-Oh, 6 April 2011) could only reach 3.5 knots with his 6 hp Honda, a 9 1/2 by 8 5/8 propeller and a boat of 1800 kg. He asked about a 10 by 6 1/4, which Honda calls a high-thrust propeller. SEGALEN (6 April 2011) said to check whether the engine reaches its rated speed at full throttle: if it does not, it is overloaded and the pitch should be reduced. plouc (6 April 2011) said a standard propeller is not suited to a Tonic: the engine runs overloaded and under-revved. After fitting a thrust propeller to the 4 hp on his Muscadet he stopped fouling the plug and shearing the propeller key, and gained 1.5 knots on top speed. Okamaugo (7 April 2011), on an Edel 4 of 1200 kg with a 9.9, gained no top speed with a high-thrust propeller but gained a reverse that had been useless. ELMOEL decided to have the engine speed checked and fit a thrust propeller.
  • A Tonic owner whose Yamaha 9.9 lost power in the well (18 August 2008, user name not shown) was told to run the engine without its cowl, because a fault that disappears points to exhaust fumes recirculating inside the cowl (deleted-8086, 18 August 2008). deleted-5523 cured the same symptom by stripping and cleaning the carburettor, the fuel bowls and the filters.
  • penthiere (16 March 2010) asked what the “well kit” recommended in the manual is. daniel13/73 guessed a forced air supply and remote control. No confirmation is in the thread.
  • A Tonic owner (19 March 2008, user name not shown) asked whether a reverse gear can be fitted to a BF6 in the well, which is on the starboard side and not at the centre. The thread has no answer.

Two enclosed-well conversions (Jeanneau Owners Network)

A Hints and Tips page of the Jeanneau Owners Network describes two owners’ changes to the well.

  • Jim Papas, a previous owner of the Tonic “Été”, enclosed the well area. He added remote controls and a through-hull exhaust to keep fumes out of the cockpit. He got a general noise reduction and very good manoeuvring; he says people think he has a small diesel.
  • Mark Weissler modified his Tonic “Kittyhawk” to take a 9.9 hp Honda four-stroke. His view: a four-stroke solves most problems of a well-mounted outboard, which are noise, fumes, fuel mixing and bad performance. The well was too small, so he cut it out with a rotary tool and a keyhole saw, then built it back up with epoxy, glass mat and gelcoat over a stiff plastic liner, and fitted a slightly stronger engine mount, epoxy-coated. Inside, steel plates take the stainless through-bolts. With a 20-inch (long) shaft Honda 9.9 four-stroke with propeller exhaust, the boat moves almost silently at low revs, with no fumes in the cabin, and the engine charges the batteries well. The shaft has not come out of the water, even in rough seas. He advises ordering the engine with a remote throttle and shift control and a short cable, because the tiller-throttle version stops the hatch from closing. He reports motoring for hours: over 240 miles on a 24-gallon tank, about 10 miles per gallon at an average of 7 knots over the ground, even while towing an inflatable dinghy. The engine ran a whole season with excellent results.

Moving the engine to the transom

  • JLPIER (25 January 2022) wanted to move his to the transom but found the engine heavy and the transom not very stiff. He knows owners who made the change and then went back to the well, so he kept it.
  • Kerare (29 December 2022) fitted a swim ladder to a Tonic transom and found it not very stiff compared with an Edel, and had to reinforce it.
  • La Contrie (13 June 2023) once saw a fin-keel Tonic converted to a bracket mount, offset because of the rudder, with the locker floor laminated, to take a bigger engine (8 or 9 hp, from memory). Gains: more power and an extra locker. Costs: more noise, looks, effort to raise and lower, and more risk to the impeller in waves.
  • A friend of golfhotel, who owns a Tonic, told him (3 December 2018) that the transom is not reinforced and that moving the engine there is a big job. The friend instead fitted a small system to carry the exhaust gases out through the transom.
  • estey (14 June 2023) posted photos of Tonics with an engine bracket, two of them sliding.
  • In the Morbihan, an owner with the engine on the transom told golfhotel it was mainly to avoid finding the well full of weed before each outing: on a mooring he keeps the engine out of the water (golfhotel, 3 December 2018).

Electric

  • Marsianer (2006) also fitted a 4.8 kW electric outboard on a rotating mount on the transom, because combustion engines are not allowed on the lake where he sails. He says it makes harbour manoeuvres easy.
  • In the Segeln-Forum, a buyer said that the electric outboards on some Tonics for sale were a deal-breaker for a trip where he might have to motor for hours (IchoTolot, 15 September 2025). Henning replied that he would test the electric motor before getting rid of it.

Sources