Check first
- Chainplates. A frequent warning. Look at the fixings, ask whether they were reinforced, and how. See the chainplates article. lulu937 (Hisse-et-Oh, 19 May 2026), looking for a Tonic, had read that this is the big flaw.
- Centreboard, case and ballast. On boats with a lifting keel or board, the lifting mechanism is often the weak link (roblisto, Zeilersforum, 5 September 2017, speaking generally; he did not know the Tonic). Check the board, and inspect the ballast from inside (earendil, Hisse-et-Oh, 15 May 2019). horstj (Segeln-Forum, 15 September 2025) lists the keel mechanism with the rig, furler, sails, shrouds, windows, gelcoat and underwater hull as the basics to check. See the centreboard article.
- Interior lining and upholstery. Apollo (Zeilersforum, 6 August 2026) says many old boats, and he thinks all Jeanneaus, have vinyl lining whose foam backing comes loose; it cannot be re-glued, so all of it has to be replaced. Expect to replace them, or look for a boat where it has been done. See the lining article.
- Windows and deck. Leaking windows are common on Jeanneaus of this period (boarderbas, 5 September 2017); look at the deck around them. See the portlights article.
- Underwater hull and osmosis. Jordi (Hisse-et-Oh, 25 January 2022) saw osmosis on a DL at the haul-out in 2018. JLPIER (same thread) found no trace of it on his boat, which Jordi thought might be the same one. Apollo (Zeilersforum, 6 August 2026) had osmosis on his own boat, though he may be the only one, and advises inspecting the underwater hull, preferably wet.
- Rudder. Breaking is a classic on these old sandwich rudders, and a broken one is probably soaked with water (JLPIER, Hisse-et-Oh, 19 October 2023). The tiller attachment on the hung rudder can rot (Herman Hartman, 6 August 2026). See the rudder article.
- Electrics. horstj (Segeln-Forum, 15 September 2025) says to inspect the installation behind the panels and linings.
- Modifications. Of a German listing, Shebee (Zeilersforum, 7 August 2026) noted that the keel had been modified and said he would have doubts; PieterV (8 August 2026) added that the transom had been rebuilt too. The boat under discussion in the Segeln-Forum was criticised as stuffed with equipment from a bigger boat, with a traveller that could not be used (horstj, nixxe and others, 15 September 2025). An unclear modification is a reason to ask questions.
- Mast foot and mast. eaumer (Hisse-et-Oh, 17 November 2024) has a broken lug on his mast foot, so the mast easily goes askew when he steps or lowers it without a crane. Ask how the mast was handled. See the mast article.
- Use. A sailing school had many Tonics, so those boats have been used a lot (jeanmar, 24 January 2015).
- Engine well. The outboard sits in a well on the starboard side. With a high-thrust propeller it cannot be lifted out of the water, because the propeller does not fit through the hole, and the off-centre engine makes manoeuvring harder (Bert65, Zeilersforum, 7 August 2026). See the outboard article.
General advice from the same Zeilersforum thread: pick the boat in the best possible condition, preferably with recent sails and engine and an owner who still cares for it (Woodstock, 7 August 2026). hnrts (6 August 2026) says that Jeanneaus of this age were built, in the French tradition, as consumer goods that wear out, so what you get depends on the care of earlier owners. Apollo (6 August 2026) says there is always more work than you expected.
Viewing reports from 2025 (Segeln-Forum)
A Swiss buyer, IchoTolot, reported three viewings in the thread (15 September to 19 October 2025). Posters often wrote prices as “18k” without a currency; the figures below read them as euros, but for the Lake Constance and Swiss boats they may be Swiss francs.
- Tonic on Lake Constance, asking about 18,000 euros (20 September). Good: electronics worked, sprayhood like new, engine ran cleanly, rudder gear stable, shrouds looked fine, chainplates had been redone. Bad: very poor wiring, genoa and cockpit covers almost gone, sheets and halyards crumbling, sails like tea towels, winches stiff, a messy boat full of clutter, cut-about anchor locker, and a strong smell of stale smoke. He judged that at 7,000 to 10,000 euros it might be worth discussing and 18,000 was a fantasy price. Quallenschubser (20 September) advised moving on: such boats need a lot of time and money, and sails, running rigging and covers would have to be renewed before a Mediterranean trip.
- Fin-keel Tonic with Swiss trailer, sailed for three hours in 10 to 12 knots (28 September). Good: realistic price, as-new high-quality sails, a boat that sails very well, running rigging like new, fairly new engine. The mainsail was slightly too small (a D22), which was no problem and maybe helpful since the boat heels quickly. Less good: the lining had been fitted badly by a previous owner, the whole water system needed redoing, no sea toilet, no sprayhood.
- Tonic in Leipzig, asking 18,500 euros (18 and 19 October). In good condition, with good sails and gear. His worry was cracks in the laminate beside the chainplates inside the boat, with threaded metal rods leading the loads into the hull. See the chainplates article. The seller sold it to someone else for 16,000 euros the same evening.
Other remarks in that thread: new shrouds, he was told, stay under 2,000 euros (Odysseus, 6 October 2025), against ChristianHH’s estimate of 7,000 to 10,000 euros for rigging and sails together (17 September 2025). A new genoa he put at 1,500 to 2,000 euros. Freshwater boats carry a higher osmosis risk (Quallenschubser, 6 October 2025), unless the boat always stood on its trailer and was only launched to sail. Buying from the trailer is possible but you must check sails and engine harder (Quallenschubser, 28 September 2025). horstj (19 October 2025) said the usual jobs are old sails and replacing the lining, which he would do in felt, and at 5,000 to 8,000 euros he would accept no major GRP damage.
Look at two boats
Henning (Segeln-Forum, 15 September 2025) advised sailing a second Tonic, without the bow thruster the boat in question carried, before deciding, because he expected a clear difference. golfhotel (Hisse-et-Oh, 16 May 2019) says to define your sailing programme first; the rest follows.
Prices people quoted
These are single remarks, in the year shown, and not a price list. On Segeln-Forum prices were often written as “14k” without a currency; they are shown as euros here, but for boats in Switzerland or on Lake Constance they may be Swiss francs.
| Date | Remark |
|---|---|
| Feb 2008 | One poster found Tonics from around 10,000 euros (voilier petit budget thread, 14 February 2008); another said a good one costs more. |
| 7 April 2008 | A DL owner paid 11,500 euros for a boat in good condition with a berth. |
| 14 December 2013 | A buyer with 4,000 to 5,000 euros had missed a Tonic at 4,500 euros. Another poster saw a fin-keel Tonic on a cradle in Villefranche, maybe advertised at 7,000 euros, with room to negotiate. |
| 15 September 2025 | A buyer in Switzerland was about to view a centreboard Tonic with a bow thruster and extras, asking around 18,000 to 18,500 euros. T1mm called 18,500 very expensive; the cheapest he knew was in Wedel (centreboard) at 5,000, and one with trailer at 14,000. tomatobrotomat put 3,000 to 4,000 euros on new standing rigging and sails. |
| 15 September to 19 October 2025 | A Lake Constance boat asked 18,000 euros (IchoTolot said 7,000 to 10,000 might be worth discussing); the Swiss fin-keel boat he sailed, at 10,500 euros, he found fair; a Lower Saxony centreboard Tonic asked 14,000 euros and went for about 12,500; a Leipzig boat asked 18,500 and sold for 16,000; a Tonic in the Eifel at 8,000 euros was suggested as worth a look, and Henning mentioned a project boat at 5,500 euros. |
| 6 to 8 August 2026 | On Zeilersforum: boarderbas says a well-kept boat can bring 6,000 to 8,000 euros; Bert65 thinks 3,300 euros is very little for a Tonic; Zwaardje found German listings from 9,999 euros. Apollo says fewer than three Tonics come on the market each year, some via brokers and many via Marktplaats or Yachtfocus. Bert65 sold his by answering someone’s “wanted” ad on botentekoop.nl. |
Documentation
Some owners kept the original test: patbzh has Bateaux magazine no. 331 of December 1985 (Hisse-et-Oh, 17 May 2019), and JLPIER (5 January 2023) has the full 1985 test from the same magazine.
Sources
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Le Tonic 23 est il un (le meilleur) choix dans mon cas” (in French): jeanmar (24 January 2015), lulu937 (19 May 2026).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Tonic 23 vs kelt 707“: earendil (15 May 2019), patbzh (17 May 2019).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “J’achète! Voilier Tonic 23 ou Jouet 24“: thread of 14 to 26 December 2013.
- Hisse-et-Oh, “voilier petit budget“: posts of 14 February 2008.
- Hisse-et-Oh, “projet de retour à la voile“: a DL owner (7 April 2008, user name not shown).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Mise à jour d’un Tonic 23.“: Jordi, JLPIER (25 January 2022).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Que pensez-vous du voilier Tonic 23“: JLPIER (5 January 2023).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “TONIC 23“: eaumer (17 November 2024).
- Zeilersforum.nl, “Jeanneau Tonic 23; waar moet ik op letten?” (in Dutch): roblisto, boarderbas (5 September 2017).
- Zeilersforum.nl, “Markt Tonic 23: deze kopen of afwachten?“: Apollo, Herman Hartman, hnrts, boarderbas, Woodstock, Bert65, Shebee, PieterV, Zwaardje (6 to 8 August 2026).
- Hisse-et-Oh, “Safran Tonic 23dl“: JLPIER (19 October 2023).
- Segeln-Forum, “Besichtigung Jeanneau Tonic 23 – Schwachstellen?” (in German; six pages): IchoTolot, horstj, T1mm, Henning, tomatobrotomat, ChristianHH, Odysseus, Quallenschubser (15 September to 19 October 2025).