Knowledge

Rigging & sails

Reefing early and sailing in a breeze

Owners agree on one rule for the Tonic 23 in a fresh wind: reduce sail early. They disagree on how much wind is too much, and some fitted or planned a smaller headsail to cope.

Last updated October 23, 2026

The rule: reduce early

  • tonic56, a former DL owner (Hisse-et-Oh, 23 June 2012): do not hesitate to reduce the mainsail quickly to keep a good course upwind in a breeze.
  • tribu, who skippered a school DL in 1995 and 1996 (24 January 2015): reduce fairly early, or the boat heels too much and slips sideways.
  • Gildas29 (11 November 2017) sailed his DL from Saint-Gilles-Croix-de-Vie to Bréhat over two months in 2017. He reports meeting 27 knots three times (force 6, checked against coastal station reports), with waves of 2 to 2.5 m, one breaking wave over 3 m at L’Herbaudière and a 3.5 m swell off Penmarch. With a recent set of sails (he stresses that this matters) and the third reef, he says the sailing was no problem. Reduce quickly to keep a light helm, because the boat tends to be ardent (weather helm). On 16 July 2018 he added that it handles more than 30 knots with good sails and three reefs, though it pounds.
  • Marsianer (Segeln-Forum, 1 September 2006) puts in the first reef from about force 4. His boat rounds up quickly in gusts at 20 to 25 degrees of heel; he suggests his sailing area (a lake) and the board being up may play a part. He led both reef lines back to the cockpit so nobody has to go forward to the mast: heave to, reef, carry on.

Where owners draw the line

  • Swanee (4 February 2008) tried the first Tonics at the Glénans in force 7 gusting 8, with 1.5 to 2 m seas between Groix and Lorient. The boats behaved acceptably close-hauled under two reefs and a storm jib, with no furler. A third reef would have been welcome. He says that beyond that they could probably not have made headway, and that in force 8 you either stay in or run for shelter.
  • Babar74 (23 January 2015) says the Tonic stays manoeuvrable up to about force 5; for family holidays he starts looking for shelter at 5 and goes in at 6.
  • tonic56 (23 January 2015): from 20 knots the boat no longer makes ground to windward and sails square tacks. His had a furling genoa. He would have fitted a removable inner stay for a storm jib.
  • A poster who followed a Tonic upwind in force 5 to 6 saw nothing wrong; the boat had taken one reef and perhaps rolled some genoa (deleted-7062, 24 January 2015). jeanmar (24 January 2015) disliked how a Tonic reacted in a strong wind and warns that school boats have had hard use.

Headsail answers

  • golfhotel (12 May 2019), refitting a DL, planned a proper reefable storm jib.
  • Kerhulcoq (12 May 2019) fitted a short rail inside the shrouds, and had a roller solent made, easier to handle than a large genoa. The solent is a triradial sail with battens on a furler, with no removable stay (25 January 2022).
  • JLPIER (25 January 2022) has a standard sail set, a mainsail and an all-purpose genoa on a Facnor furler, and no removable stay.

Light weather and downwind

  • A “Booster” (a double jib for full downwind sailing, as GRIBOU246 explained on 23 July 2017) was used folded in half as a big genoa in light air by Julirosien on his Kelt 707 (9 August 2017).
  • An asymmetric spinnaker was called indispensable by an owner in April 2008, who gave its price new as 720 euros. patbzh (2 March 2018) asked how to mount a bowsprit for one he had been given; WTS (8 March 2022) planned a removable bowsprit to move the tack of his asymmetric spinnaker forward.
  • vrobert78 (9 August 2019) reached 9.8 knots over the ground under spinnaker on a run from Trébeurden to Paimpol, and regularly sees about 6 knots on the log.

Other points

  • A poster suggested (19 May 2019) that sudden luffs may come from too much mast rake, a tuning matter. He did not say this had been tried.
  • blito (25 January 2015) names the size of the cockpit and the low boom, set by the cabin below it, as the only complaint he has about the boat.

Sources